I did not realize that. Well, that is pretty disappointing considering that WDW's website specifically states:
- Guests Staying in Club-Level Rooms or Suites: If you have a confirmed reservation for a Club-level room or suite at a Walt Disney World Resort hotel, a Disney Signature Services Cast Member will contact you to begin the pre-planning process. They’ll provide you with their email address and phone number so you can contact them directly to plan and book outstanding experiences for your Walt Disney World vacation.
Granted, I can recall in the past them contacting me well after I already had all my dining booked, but at least it was a contact.
I have not personally done it, but I have been between Christmas and New Years, and I have close friends who have been during spring break, and I would absolutely spend the extra money to get the 3 extra FP during either of those time periods. For me, that would be worth it as you would know that you were avoiding the tiers and avoiding at least 6 of those long lines for the popular rides. The question would be whether the program will still be in existence by Spring Break.