Just playing catch up again. Sorry. Ignore it if you like, it's a little dated.
Well, an awful lot has gone on over the past few days. Lets see if we can get back on track. At least the track Im interested in.
Mr. Bear,
What if all of the new hotels weren't built by Eisner, but by a mix of chains, without any Disney theming?
I dont mean to sound demeaning or overly simplistic, but SO WHAT!?
I mean do you call Pop Century Disney Theming? I dont. And to varying degrees ALL the resorts built under Ei$ners careful reign fall into the same category. NONE were built with true Disney Theming. And even the rehabs and additions to the two originals have taken away from the primary concepts.
If the parks had been spun off separately, it probably would have been saddled with license agreements and such which siphoned off a good bit of the park revenue stream anyway. And who's to say that a separate park company would have any better management than the current regime?
Yes there may have been some money drained, but do you really think it would have been as severe as it has been had there been no (just shy of a) billion dollar internet fiasco, covering ABCs financial butt and the CEOs private bank account? I dont.
And Im not saying we might not be in the same shape, Im just saying, in response to your assertions that Ei$ner
SAVED the company, that wed be no worse off and with just a little bit of luck we might have gotten a guy who Got it. And thats really half the battle!!
The idea that the hotels and other development were built with no "plan" is preposterous. Disney has plans upon plans upon plans for the property.
Preposterous, eh? OK. Maybe its the NO that got you. How about poor? How about little? How about plans upon plans with no rhyme or reason, whatever will fit, lets just plop a hotel here kind of plans?
What happened to the master plan for the property? Or if they hated that one, how about doing another of your own, with some sort of cohesive thought for the property, and an eye toward future growth. How about laying out a plan that actually takes the guests comfort, driving, transportation and architectural ambience into account? How about that kind of plan?
No. You are right Mr. Bear. I did misspeak. I said no plans. And there have been, as you so aptly pointed out, plans upon plans. And I agree. Way too many plans to suit me. Its like the weather in Chicago. You dont like? Hang around five minutes. Itll change.
Oh, so Katzenberg's the creative genius.
I think AV and others covered that one. But, as for why EI$ner will never be good at it? Hes a micro-manager. He always has been and he always will be. And that just plain doesnt work without a whole bunch of talent in you. And he aint got that either!!
Somewhat overbuilt or not, isn't it clear that Demon Mike has been successful in the plan to keep folks on the property for extended visits?
Oh! I quite agree, Mr. Bear. Yes!! Yes, indeed!! You will never get an argument out of me on this point. He is very good at exchanging the short term profit for the long term interest. Hes very good at mortgaging the future to meet the demands of the present. Hes a master at beating his next quarter. But at what price? Thats the ultimate question. At what price!?!?! I personally think the price is much, much, much too high!!
Good stab at Pop Century--I don't like it either, but we'll see how the public takes to it. Swan and Dolphin, though, are an Eisner triumph IMO--love that Michael Graves' stuff.
OH MY GOD!!!! Go back to your first paragraph!! Where is the Disney theme? Where is the Disney touch? Where is the Disney ANYTHING?!?!?
You may like the look, and if they were on International Drive I might agree! But come on, Mr. Bear!! In Disney!?!?! Within the sight lines of EPCOT!?!?! Behind the Eiffel Tower, an upside-down cartoon looking fish! Whatd ya thinkin!?!?!
Scoop, you are just so silly sometimes.
Why? Because everything, EVERYTHING, has weaknesses. And, when you are set on finding a weakness, it can be done.
And sometimes it just jumps out and slaps you in the face. Dinorama anyone? DCA? Pop Century? Do we need to go on?
The same way that Alladin's Magical Carpets, Philarmagic, Saratoga Springs and many others are great for what they are.
Surely you can do better than this? One spinner ride that definitely detracts from the magic of the area (remember Scoop, I was a lone voice of car #3 that didnt want to judge this ride before I saw it) and two items that arent even opened yet!!
Dont you see how this type of talk just adds to the perception that you view Disney with rose colored glasses! All they have to do is announce something is coming and Scoop not only thinks its the greatest thing to hit Disney, he puts it in writing on the internet!!! And uses it as an argument that things are getting better!!!!
I think Ill take my standard approach and wait and see if it lives up to expectations or exceeds them. (Maybe you should wait to. Ill bet Greg already copied this and is saving it for a year from now!!)