This makes me wonder how people decide between accumulation and usage. 400k of UR seems like a lot (to me). We've had CSP (P1 and P2) for just about 2 years and have about 250k between us. Obviously part of each of those was the SUB. We have plans to travel to Ireland for 2 weeks in 2023 so my first thought was to just keep accumulating, but we also have travel plans this summer. I feel like I can't convince myself to use any points. (we don't dabble with Biz cards, so our total points across programs is probably lower than many)
Anyone want to share their accumulate/spend philosophy?
That's a great question and I'll bite...
I historically am an earn and burn and earn person. I'm a Delta captive so Skymiles seem to just...evaporate (lol). That said, with travel being odd, this year I had a random goal for MRs and recently accomplished that (then immediately transferred to BA, KLM and Delta and of course a chunk of Delta disappeared
).
So, especially since AmEx passes along the tax on domestic carrier miles, I try to never transfer MRs to DL unless I have >165K (since the tax charged is capped at $99-yes, a bit spiteful I'll admit), so I'm perpetually working on having at least 200K in Amex MR at any time (right now it's at a sad, sad 11K).
Skymiles I don't really stockpile unless I know I have a flight to arrange within a few months, but I do like to have enough on hand for an emergency flight to CA (ILs live there and are old) or MA (DD is in school there), so maybe around 50K in either my stash, DH's or DD's (I have access to them all).
United is similar to Delta, although I have a (much larger) stash from cancelled flights in 2020.
URs are definitely valuable and I usually try to keep enough for last minute hotel or flight transfers. Since I have enough United miles, normally I'd transfer them all to Hyatt but right now I'm pretty solid on Hyatt so they're just hanging out in my account (well, except for the PYB I just used on my newest Away carry on, lol).
Marriott-I like to keep around 50-100K for last minute trips, whereas I'm a Hyatt girl who loves Miraval so I like to keep at least 3 nights there in a stash.
I also have a composition notebook with travel dreams and the programs best suited for accomplishing them (usually 2-4 if possible), with an estimate of points/miles necessary. For instance, before I flew to Australia, I knew I wanted to fly in business or first class. At the time it looked like I'd need the following- United-goal of 400K miles, Delta-goal of 1 Million (laughable I know), 500K in MRs via Virgin Australia and American 110-220K miles. With this outline, I was able to pivot away from United and Delta miles to fly to Australia in First Class on Qantas via American miles (220K total 1 way for 2 in first) and then back in Virgin Australia for 253,604 MRs total (390,160 before the 35% biz plat rebate 1 way for 2 in business).
TL;DR-
I balance the juggling act of draining some programs while replenishing others.
I try to keep a minimum of 50-100K in most accounts-I've found that will cover emergencies and then as my travel plans evolve, I can put my energy toward accrual of the program necessary for my next trips.