I've been on and off the boards for years and I've been watching the videos for a few months now, even binge watching old episodes and I don't find the team to be jaded. In fact, they tend to love some of the smaller and simpler things like People Mover (which my daughter and have decided will be my granddaughter's first ride), Carousel of Progress, and Small World (which my daughter won't ride any longer due to an unfortunate incident where we were stuck for a prolonged time). They expect value, service, and things to generally meet the standards that Disney set for themselves. I appreciate it when they let me know whether things are up to par or not. They are also good to point out that they are giving their opinions on things and that people should decide for themselves. For me, they have a good balance of in & out of studio stuff, with the between-trip updates and news I'm looking for.
I can get DISers' opinions on the boards (we are an opinionated group). And if I want to see some random family, I can search YouTube... there are a LOT out there.