I called 407-560-2428
I was still told no. They said if no tickets are for sale .. they are "sold out" and can't sell them.
I think you are out of luck like I am.
When I explained that I wouldn't be ADDING to the capacity .. just using a different type of ticket to enter the park (with my current reservation) .. they still seemed like it couldn't happen. "You have to cancel your current reservation . and make a new one when you buy a new ticket and since the system won't let you buy a ticket, you are out of luck." "If you want to go the parks .. just use your current ticket (activate your annual pass)".
I essentially want to "downgrade" one of my tickets. It seems silly .. I get the park is full. I get that if I decided last minute to go to WDW that I couldn't (because the park is full) .. But I am "on the list" and have valid tickets for the family (which is why I was able to get "on the list").. I just want to buy/use a single day ticket instead of the ones I have in hand. I don't see why this is an issue besides the CMs I have talked to just limited by the system. Someone somewhere should be able to override the system.
It seems silly .. I am WILLING to throw $130+ of NEW money to Disney (plus souvenirs/food) to go for just ONE DAY . .but apparently they don't want me, so instead of getting hundreds of dollars from me.. they will be getting $0 and I am taking up the spots of four other people that COULD be going and spending money.
I am almost tempted to just go and try and pass off my daughter as a 3 year old .. she is unfortunately 4 1/2 ..
I may try one last ditch effort to go to Disney Springs Ticket Center and explain my case .. but if they don't want my money .. I will just take it their competitors .. like Sea World.