Thanks for creating a happy moment for me. This quote threw me back to my college days - a journey of more than 45 years. But having gone to a small religious college where four semesters of philosophy were a core requirement, I recognized it immediately.
I imagine Kant would feature well in a religious college, he was a devout Christian and saw ethics as a duty to both fellow man and God. I actually hate reading Kant, despite liking what he says. Nietzsche said something like, "Kant attempts to say, in a way the common man would hate, that the common man has it right all along." Oddly enough, I love reading Nietzsche, despite disagreeing with much of what he says.
Between Kant and Aristotle there is everything a person needs to know how to be decent to each other.
It’s really hard to see people claim that masks are here to stay and we should get used to them. I don’t want to live my life shut in my house, but I really don’t want to live the rest of my life in a mask.
It's going to be a hard year or two coming then. I hope that a greater variety of mask styles are developed and marketed and that you find one that is comfortable.
We also have no mortgage & no debt plus making huge overtime so money (don't know why that was brought up) is not the issue. So are we supposed to compare financials? The issue is self preservation.
My point was only that, in practical terms, the choice to put one's self in that room or not is tied to one's means. A trait that is only mostly within our own control at the best of times.
I do not know why people feel the need to reinterpret what someone wrote, why the need to add -what if, could be, would've , could've. should've.
Because the question, as written, is an abstraction. It is meant to represent the core elements of any number of specific hypothetical situations. For one person it might be the need to get their license renewed in person and spending an hour in a large waiting room. Perhaps a spouse or child on the other side of the country is critically injured and to spend their last moments with them you must get in a plane with 100 other people. Or to get home from vacation you have to gather with a large group of strangers and wait for a seating assignment.
There's a infinite array of potential situations, the specifics of which boil down neatly to,'"You find yourself stuck in an enclosed space with a large number of people, one of them or yourself is contagious with covid-19." In this situation how many of the people would you prefer be wearing a face mask'
I speak for us - and let me reiterate - I would NEVER EVER EVER EVER put myself in that situation.
Always be wary that Nemesis often follows Hubris.
Would you at least agree that not everyone in that situation has
put themselves in that situation? But the question does not concern itself with what situations you would choose for yourself, it presupposes that anyone may
find themselves in this situation.
Did that cashier that has to go to work or risk losing their family home; or that mother, boarding a plane for LA to see her son before they turn the machines off, did they choose to put themselves in this situation? Obviously its within their power to choose not to, and yet when the stakes balance in such a way, choice or not becomes a distinction without a difference.
No one can say that they will never find themselves in this situation. Because things that might place one in this situation happen every day completely divorced from our own personal agency.
The puzzle or inquiry is not whether you will ever be in this spot, odds are you won't. But you could be... and should that happen... would you prefer you and those sharing that space with you be wearing a mask, or not?
This is a different question than just asking if you think wearing masks is a good idea or asking if a person will wear a mask. It asks you to put yourself in the shoes of those thousands of people in each of our communities that must put themselves in a space with people every day. You know at least a couple people out of the thousands walking through a grocery store each shift are gonna have coronavirus. Even in a smaller town, if one of them doesn't have it today it then it will happen the next day or maybe the next. Put yourself in the shoes of a policeman or EMT. Put yourself in the shoes of future-you going through something you never considered before.
Is your decision to wear or not wear a mask a maxim you would make universal?