Originally posted by las3888
I wouldn't really consider not tipping for services rendered to bellhops, but why should I pay for their services to move my bags, when it is their job? Why do I not tip for the services of the front desk people, the guard who checks my parking pass as I go through the gate, the people who work in the shops, the people taking my order at the counter service, the person I rent a bicycle from, or the lifeguard? These people are all performing their duties, plus not getting paid a whole heck of a lot. I just don't think that using a bellhop should be differentiated from these other service jobs.
All good questions. A waitress gets tipped but a flight attendant who serves you lunch doesn't. The curbside skycap who checks your luggage gets tipped but wait in line inside and the airline employee who checks your luggage doesn't. I agree alot of this isn't consistent (or even fair). I agree with your conclusion, you really "have" to tip people who do work for you if tipping is a major (or only) source of their compensation.